top of page

The Diminishing Returns of Dealership Advertising - Insight Vol. 37

Writer: Phil Villegas
Phil Villegas
5 hours ago
5 min read

BY TYSON FISHER


If you have sat across the desk from an advertising vendor recently, you have probably heard a version of the same pitch. “If you are not getting enough traction, you are not spending enough.” It is a convenient diagnosis, because the prescription is always a bigger invoice. But as a business manager, all you see is increased spending per retail unit in a diminishing PVR environment. After years of working inside dealership and independent automotive repair financials, I can tell you that the budget is rarely the real problem. The real problem is targeting the wrong customer and running advertising with no guardrails on where the money goes and no internal controls over advertising spending.


Vendors pitch that more investment equals more returns. In reality, advertising has diminishing returns: the first dollars spent on the right customer work hard, and each extra dollar buys less, until you are paying to reach uninterested people.



Advertising is quintessential to competing in automotive retail. Your competitors are bidding on the same customers in the same auctions, and going dark is not an option. But there is a difference between spending to compete and spending yourself out of your own margins. When advertising per retail unit creeps up quarter after quarter without a corresponding lift in volume or gross margins, you are not buying growth; you are donating gross profit to your advertising vendors.


The Rarely Questioned Account


Advertising is one of the broadest, most loosely defined accounts on a dealership’s financial statement, and employees know it. We have seen sports tickets, dinners out, and golf outings coded to advertising because “it builds the brand.” A lot of it is personal spending in a marketing costume. An account that absorbs six or seven figures a year with minimal line-item review is a comfortable place to park personal expenses nobody wants questioned.


Traditional Advertising Still Has a Place


Depending on your market, traditional advertising still earns its keep, and its highest and best use is your existing customer base. A well timed mailer, handwritten letter, or call campaign aimed at customers who have not been in for service in nine to 12 months is one of the cheapest triggers available to you. Reactivating them costs a fraction of targeting a stranger, and the service relationship feeds your next vehicle sale.


Where the Online Dollars Actually Go


Google is really three products for dealers, and they behave very differently.


  • Paid Search (AdWords)

    Paid search captures demand from high-intent consumers. When a customer types “used Silverado near me,” they have intent, and paid search puts your store in front of that intent. The catch is that it requires active management. Keywords, negative keywords, bids, and geographies need regular attention. Left on autopilot with increasing daily budgets, search campaigns bloat with irrelevant clicks that spend your budget and produce nothing.


  • Local Services Ads (LSAs)

    LSAs are broad by design and suit dealer groups with large brand coverage across a region. For a single-brand owner or a targeted segment (luxury vs. light-duty), they cast a net far wider than your customer base, at a substantially higher rate. Google refunds poor leads, but without broad brand coverage, the spend rarely pays.


  • Performance Max

    Performance Max is Google’s AI-driven product that spreads your budget across search, YouTube, display, Gmail, and maps. It can genuinely perform with real ads, and when it works, it works across channels you would never manage individually. The caveat is that it is a black box with low guardrails. You hand Google a budget and a goal, and your visibility into where the money actually went is limited. If you run Performance Max, watch the outcomes vigilantly because you cannot watch the inputs.


Facebook, Meta, and TikTok bring a different strength, which is audience building. You can load your own customer lists from your DMS and CRM to build proprietary audiences, then market to lookalike audiences that resemble your best customers. Meta is excellent for branding, and it can be great for selling when the creative and the targeting are managed well. It can also quietly burn money on impressions nobody remembers when they are not managed well.


Your website is the destination every other channel is paying to reach. A site that loads slowly, shows stale inventory, or buries service scheduling three menus deep is the online version of a disorganized lot with unpriced inventory and nobody to greet the customer. Before increasing any channel budget, make sure the store you are sending traffic to closes sales and increases repair order count.


Programmatic advertising can be excellent when done effectively, but it must have guardrails, and it demands that you know your customer and your regions. The appeal is precision. You can get hyper-granular, showing Mercedes-Benz and Porsche inventory only in the high-income areas of your city, or Honda ads to people who have only visited Honda websites, and you can even build campaigns around specific vehicles. The risk mirrors Google’s Performance Max, discussed earlier—without defined geographies, frequency caps, audience definitions, and consistent monitoring, programmatic advertising will happily spend an unlimited budget with very little to show for it.


Make the Channels Talk to Each Other


The best-performing stores link the channels. A properly installed Meta pixel and Google tags let the platforms see who visited your site and what they viewed, then retarget those shoppers across platforms. If your vendors have never discussed pixel and tag integration, you are paying each platform to find the same customer from scratch.


Why Guardrails, and Why Now


The common thread through all of this is that advertising rewards whoever is paying attention and punishes whoever is not. The account is broad and general by nature, which is exactly why it drifts. Budgets broaden and advertising campaigns run long past their usefulness. Personal items slide into the spending, and occasionally people in positions of trust abuse that generality outright, approving spending inside a budget that nobody else fully understands or reviews. The dollar amounts are rarely large enough to jump off a monthly statement, but they compound, and they compound at the expense of your bottom line.


If your advertising spending per retail unit feels heavy, if you are spending real money with no visible return, or if you are simply not getting straight answers about why the advertising budget keeps growing, it is time for a review of your vendors and your advertising spending.


  1. Pull the invoices

  2. Ask each vendor what you bought, who saw it, and what it produced

  3. Validate the vendors and their registered agents

  4. Ask who approved each campaign and who reviews the account detail every month


The vendors and managers doing right by you will welcome the questions. The ones who get defensive just told you where to look.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page